Superstars of the Hall of Fame

Chamelion
Corey Lazarus
The Corpse
Dalton "The Spider" Campbell
Dr. Steven Remo
Fear
Gabrielle
Jacob Figgins
Jamie Flynn
Jay
Jethro Hayes
Marcus Collins
Mark McNasty
Matthew Engel
Matt Stone
Metalhead
Mikey P
Monkey McDee
Nightstryker
Panzadise
Phoenix *Rob Robinson*
Prima Donna
Project X
Psycho Sandra
Rage
Raizzor
Reese
Riona Langly
Scott Nash Strader
Scottie 'The Panther' Snow
Showtime
Simon Kalis
Sirus
Thunderwolf
Tundra

Tag Teams of the Hall of Fame

The Brothers Grimm
ICONs
Sudden Impact
Cowgirls From Hell
OoC (Simon/Adrian)
Might and Magic

Stables of the Hall of Fame

Masters of Apocalypse
the Moran Clan
Order of Chas (Simon, Adrian, Maya, SNS, MNS, TNS)

Managers of the Hall of Fame

'Al' (Moran Clan member, usually seen with Sirus)
Vanessa Strader (managed Cowboys and Cowgirls from Hell as well as every Strader that has wrestled in the time period of her 25 year career)

Front Office (OOC) Champions of the Hall of Fame

Alex Wilcox
Andre Thomas
Ben Duke
Chris Bitner
Sir Figgy
Harpreet Setia
Jarett Charowsky
Joe Kanzleiter
Matt Leistikow-Starbuck
Richard 'Bean' Bennett
Rob Robinson